Monday, December 23, 2013

What is it about money?

I was going to hold off blogging until the New Year, but irritation drove me to posting ...

In a recent article, Alan Kohler had this to say:
The real war is between monetary policy and the Digital Revolution – between the world of finance trying to reduce the value of money and therefore debt, and the world of technology pushing for greater efficiency and productivity, to drive prices lower and the value of money higher.
Why does money make perfectly sensible economists and economic commentators forget elementary economics? Money is a good. Fine, it is a special type of good, it is a transaction good--something used to facilitate transactions.  We use money, not because it has production or consumption utility--the paper or polymer notes we use as money has no interesting element of either--but because it has transaction utility (expected utility in future transactions).

Nevertheless, money is a good. The price of goods in a market is set by supply and demand. Sure, the price (in the sense of the swap value) of money is the inverse of the price for all other goods and services. That is, if P is the price level, the swap value of a unit of money is 1/P. (The money price of money is itself; i.e. the money price of x dollars in dollars is x dollars.)  Still, the price (swap value) of money is a supply-and-demand matter.

Since the supply of money need not be fixed--the joy of a token-money central bank is it can produce any amount of the tokens we use as money--there is no necessary effect for any amount of extra productivity to do anything to the price (i.e. swap value) of money. Productivity and output tell you nothing on their own about the swap value of money and thus the price level.

If you don't believe me, ask the Zimbabweans. Zimbabwe has no currency of its own any more (Wikipedia labels its currency as "various"), because its central bank under Governor Gideon Gono was so profligate in printing money that hyperinflation got to an estimated 6.5 sextillion % in November 2008. In January 2009, Zimbabweans were legally able to use other currencies and shortly thereafter the Zimbabwean government stopped issuing currency. Whatever was happening to Zimbabwean productivity was rather beside the point in the face of such currency profligacy.

Gold standard effects
Kohler cites the deflationary experience of the C19th as supporting his view of the deflationary consequences of higher productivity:
During the second half of the 19th century prices fell consistently – that is, there was deflation – because of the impact on productivity of the Industrial Revolution. Between 1870 and 1900 the purchasing power of the US dollar doubled as prices came down.
Yes, there was a prolonged deflationary period in the latter C19th. The US, Germany and France all went on the gold standard in 1873. Under the gold standard, the price of gold sets the the price of money since money has a set exchange of rate of money into gold. So, if output of goods and services rises faster than the stock of gold--as happened in the gold zone from 1873 to 1896--then there will be deflation.

Conversely, if gold production outstrips growth in output of goods and services--as happened from 1896 to 1914 due to the Kalgoorlie/Coolgardie and Klondike gold rushes coming on top of the earlier Witwatersrand gold rush--then there will be inflation.

The Industrial Revolution did not suddenly go into reverse in 1896. Just as the current plunge in the Greek price level is not due to surging Greek productivity.

Sure, rising output and increasing productivity put downward pressure on prices. But whether this will have deflationary consequences depends on what is happening (and expected to happen) with money. Kohler is breaking Sumner's dictum--never reason from a price change. (Or, in this case, a price level change). Price, it is a supply AND demand matter. Including for money. Money may be special, but it is not that special. The gold zone deflation followed by the gold zone inflation were a gold-production and goods-and-services-output story, not just a goods-and-services-output story.

Good and bad deflation
As it happens, I agree that rising output and productivity was an important part of the 1873-1896 story, but not quite the way Kohler tells it. It helps explain why the 1870s expansion of the gold standard was bad for Britain, provided one understands the different sorts of deflation. For deflation can be divided into the good, the bad and the ugly (pdf).

Germany was in the process of industrialising: it could import millions of peasants into its cities, and did. The US was also in the process of industrialising and incorporating its westward expansion into its economic system. It could import millions of migrants into is cities, and did. In other words, Germany and the US had lots of inputs to add to their industrialising economies. Germany also received the institutional and transaction cost benefits of unification while the US received the institutional benefits of establishing a stable post-Civil War constitutional regime with the Compromise of 1877. To a significant extent, Germany and the US experienced "good deflation" (the downward pressure on prices of expanding output due to expanding, and more efficient use of, inputs). In other words, their aggregate supply curves kept shifting rightwards (i.e. producing more for a given price level).

Rising productivity (good),
falling demand (bad),
collapsing incomes (ugly).
By the 1870s, Britain was already highly urbanised, highly industrialised and its institutions were about as economically efficient as was achievable without major political pain. There was not a lot of good deflation to be had. So, they experienced more "bad deflation" (downward pressure on nominal income/aggregate demand) due to growth in output of goods and services being higher than growth in the stock of gold. With income prospects therefore relatively poor in the UK, capital flowed out to the US, Germany and other places where returns were easier. (Throughout this post, income means money or nominal income.) Hence the UK falling behind the US and Germany in economic growth and industrial modernisation. (The US and UK had similar levels of per capita economic growth for much of the C19th: the US per capita growth rate only shifted above Britain's in the 1870s.)

The Euro is like an artificial gold standard. Just as entering the gold zone was about a pound sterling for everyone, so the Eurozone was a Deutschmark for everyone. And just as the initial expansion of the gold zone was bad for Britain, so too there was a similar adverse effect for Germany in the creation of the Eurozone. But Germany then went through a series of supply-side reforms (particularly labour market reforms) which put it in a much better position. German adjustment was helped by higher income growth in the Mediterranean countries; now it is the latter countries who need to do painful adjustments to make the Euro work, Germany is refusing to return the favour of accepting higher nominal income growth via higher inflation.

Inflation targeting
Applying the lessons of the 1873-1914 apotheosis of the gold standard, and grasping how simple inflation targeting is somewhat like the gold standard, enables us to see what is actually behind the phenomena Kohler is discussing.

Kohler writes that:
When the Industrial Revolution reduced costs, debt wasn’t an issue and prices could be allowed to fall. In fact, society’s most powerful were savers, not borrowers: for them deflation was a good thing so they made sure it happened.
This time around it’s different: borrowers are ascendant and central banks are working for them, not savers. In fact, savers are being plundered with super low interest in the name of promoting aggregate demand and maintaining inflation.
Pausing here, if it is all about rising productivity, how did savers "make sure" deflation happened? By insisting on a certain monetary policy regime perhaps?

The cross of gold.
But Kohler is right in that deflation is nastier for debtors. But so is any collapse in income expectations (and income), since debtors rely on expected income to remain solvent.

Of course, a collapse in income expectations and income also becomes rapidly a problem for creditors, as their debt-assets (one person's liability is another person's asset) become increasingly threatened the sharper and more sustained the collapse in income and income expectations is. The problem with the Great Depression was "ugly" deflation--a massive and sustained drop in prices leading to a massive and sustained drop in income (since income = price x quantity) leading to mass insolvencies and financial collapses and crises.

Why was there a massive drop in prices? Because central banks (led by the Bank of France) hoarded gold, driving up its price, and therefore the price of money--which was at fixed exchange rates to gold--therefore driving down the price level in the gold zone (since the price level is the reciprocal of the swap value of money). Which then drove down incomes.

With both the gold standard and simple inflation targeting, the central bank takes responsibility for the maintaing the "value" of the currency (either in gold or on a set rate of change of the price level) but no responsibility for income expectations. So, if income expectations crash, that's unfortunate but does not lead to any change in the policy regime. (Until, of course, it does--such as by abandoning the gold standard.)

Recovery from such a transactions crash requires that income expectations recover. Such as due to an expected sustained rise in the price level.

Which is clearly not part of current expectations. Inflation has been low because central banks are making keeping inflation down their central priority and are very credible on that point.

As it happens, there is a productivity price norm (pdf) which Hayek and Keynes almost agreed on (pdf) where productivity shifts drive monetary policy. Keynes was a firm supporter of a stable price level; Keynesianism may be associated in some quarters with inflationary policies but, in this matter, Keynes was clearly not a Keynesian. A case of Etienne Gilson's point that the conclusions of the master are the premises of the disciple (who therefore fail to end up in quite the same place). But the productivity price norm is an explicit monetary policy regime, it is not some "natural" consequence of rising productivity.

The secular trend to low interest rates over recent decades are a product of rising incomes in China, India and most of Asia in between, leading to high savings rates. So saving has been "pushing on" investment, in a low inflation environment, hence low interest rates. Low interest rates are usually a sign that money has been relatively tight (i.e. the expected path of money is low compared to the expected path of output). So, once again we are back to supply and demand and the monetary policy regime.

Kohler's story of central banks heroically fighting the threat of rising productivity is fairy tale stuff. Worse, it is a fairy tale that allows central banks to evade responsibility for their actions. But ignoring the role of money and monetary policy in economic cycles does that. Acknowledging that supply and demand matter for money too--a point of elementary economics--would be a good start.

[Cross-posted at Skepticlawyer.]

22 comments:

  1. Lorenzo: Yep. Good clear post. I had a similar reaction on reading that Alan Kohler article.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hello everyone!! I was diagnosed of Genital Herpes Simplex Virus (HSV) in 2015 and I have tried all possible means to get cured, i even visited Some Hospital where they gave me some drugs like Famvir, Zovirax and Valtrex which are very expensive but all to no avail, until i saw a post in a health forum about a herbal doctor from West Africa who prepare herbal medicine to cure all kind of diseases including Herpes Simplex Virus, at first i doubted if it was real but decided to give it a try, when i contact this herbal doctor via his email he sent me a herbal medicine through courier service, when i received this herbal medicine, he gave me step by instructions on how to apply it, when i applied it as instructed i was totally cured of this deadly disease within 12-14 days of usage, if you are suffering of this diseases you can as well Contact this great herbal doctor via his email; dr.osocuringhome@gmail.com

      Delete
    2. HELLO. I am happy and satisfied that is why i choose to support other patient that do not know about Dr Enoma, he cured me with his herbs and he also cured some patient i directed to him of HIV, Cancer Kidney stone, Diabetes etc. I am not ashamed to tell about how i suffered of Herpes for 16 years because i am completely negative now. Dr Enoma cured me and made my family happy again. you can contact him if you have any health issue. i assure you that you will get your desire granted through the help of Dr Enoma. contact him with his Email: dr.enomaspellhome@gmail.com or Call/Whatsapp +254785389290 FACEBOOK PAGE: https://www.facebook.com/dr.enomaherbalcure


      HELLO. I am happy and satisfied that is why i choose to support other patient that do not know about Dr Enoma, he cured me with his herbs and he also cured some patient i directed to him of HIV, Cancer Kidney stone, Diabetes etc. I am not ashamed to tell about how i suffered of Herpes for 16 years because i am completely negative now. Dr Enoma cured me and made my family happy again. you can contact him if you have any health issue. i assure you that you will get your desire granted through the help of Dr Enoma. contact him with his Email: dr.enomaspellhome@gmail.com or Call/Whatsapp +254785389290 FACEBOOK PAGE: https://www.facebook.com/dr.enomaherbalcure




      HELLO. I am happy and satisfied that is why i choose to support other patient that do not know about Dr Enoma, he cured me with his herbs and he also cured some patient i directed to him of HIV, Cancer Kidney stone, Diabetes etc. I am not ashamed to tell about how i suffered of Herpes for 16 years because i am completely negative now. Dr Enoma cured me and made my family happy again. you can contact him if you have any health issue. i assure you that you will get your desire granted through the help of Dr Enoma. contact him with his Email: dr.enomaspellhome@gmail.com or Call/Whatsapp +254785389290 FACEBOOK PAGE: https://www.facebook.com/dr.enomaherbalcure



      HELLO. I am happy and satisfied that is why i choose to support other patient that do not know about Dr Enoma, he cured me with his herbs and he also cured some patient i directed to him of HIV, Cancer Kidney stone, Diabetes etc. I am not ashamed to tell about how i suffered of Herpes for 16 years because i am completely negative now. Dr Enoma cured me and made my family happy again. you can contact him if you have any health issue. i assure you that you will get your desire granted through the help of Dr Enoma. contact him with his Email: dr.enomaspellhome@gmail.com or Call/Whatsapp +254785389290 FACEBOOK PAGE: https://www.facebook.com/dr.enomaherbalcure

      Delete
    3. Though i haven't met DR Unuareghe but i have being hearing and seeing his
      wonderful deeds on people's life.. This made me contacted him because i was
      also diagnosed of herpes virus, When i contacted Him, without wasting time, he
      started his Miraculous work in my Life, I am happy and Glad to say that i
      am now cured after using his herbal Medicine.. You can also reach him
      dr.unuareghecuringhome@gmail..com or reach him on +2349067894643 he also
      special on curing
      1...HERPES CURE
      2...ALS CURE
      3..HIV CURE
      4.EPILEPSY
      5...PROMOTION IN THE OFFICE
      6...LOVE SPELL
      7>>EX BACK

      Delete
  2. "Yes, there was a prolonged deflationary period in the latter C19th. The US, Germany and France all went on the gold standard in 1873. Under the gold standard, the price of gold sets the the price of money since money has a set exchange of rate of money into gold. So, if output of goods and services rises faster than the stock of gold--as happened in the gold zone from 1873 to 1896--then there will be deflation."

    This depends on the elasticity of demand for gold. The move to the gold standard made demand for gold more inelastic, so movement in GDP might actually exert a greater effect on prices than otherwise. According to my own estimates, after the gold rush, but before 1873, the elasticity of prices with respect to GDP was less than 1. When the range expands to 1896 or beyond, the estimate rises to about 1.5. Production could not have had this sort of impact on prices if base money substitutes for gold were not excluded. Even "good" deflation is not necessary deflation. In fact, decreased elasticity of demand for gold is what led to the gold standards destruction.

    *See some of my results here:

    http://moneymarketsandmisperceptions.blogspot.com/2013/12/hawtreys-narrative-and-my-critique-of.html

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I was abstracting away from the issue of shifts in the demand for gold (until I got to the Great Depression). Nor is it surprising that expanding the monetary role of gold would tend to make demand for it more inelastic and interact more strongly with changes in output. And yes, I found Milton Friedman's argument that bimetallism would have been stabilising quite plausible.

      I sometimes wonder if the BoE's role in 1873-1914 was to stabilise demand for gold. Using the G = kPy equation, its primes inter pares role would there to have been to make sure k did not shift around too much, a role that the interwar Fed failed to fulfil after Strong's death.

      Delete
    2. "I sometimes wonder if the BoE's role in 1873-1914 was to stabilise demand for gold. Using the G = kPy equation, its primes inter pares role would there to have been to make sure k did not shift around too "

      That's worth considering. I plan to get in to Sayer's volumes on the BoE some time during the next year. Even a rudimentary understanding might encourage that, although the attempt, if it occurred, could throw other factors out of balance. And coordination of policies with other banks would be prerequisite. That is what happened after 1913. It is especially difficult for independent central banks to coordinate policy.

      Delete
    3. Continuing that line of thought, the "rules" of the classical gold standard would then have been a way for central banks to manage expectations about their behaviour (especially to each other).

      Delete
    4. I USED TO HAVE HERPES,,,AND I WORK WITH THE U.S ARMY IM 35yrs old ...... SUFFERING FROM HERPES I LOOKED FOR CURE ALMOST ROUND THE WORLD VISING WORLD KNOW BEST HOSPITALS ,NOT UNTIL I CONTACTED A GREAT SPIRITUALIST ONLINE THROUGH THE HELP OF A FRIEND LISA,I NARRATED MY PREDICAMENT TO HIM,I WAS SHOCKED SHE SAID''NO CAUSE FOR ALARM'''I SEND HIM MY PHOTO,,,,HE SAID HE WILL NEED TO BUY SOME ITEMS,AND I PAID FOR IT...AFTER SEVEN DAYS HE TOLD ME TO GO FOR TEST AGAIN,...... MY FRIENDS YOU WON'T BELIEVE IT WAS NEGATIVE....NOW I'M SOUND AND HEALTHY STILL WORKING WITH THE U.S ARMY. I BELIEVE HE CAN CURE ANY TYPE OF SICKNESS HIV AIDS CANCER ETC HIS EMAIL ADDRESS IS: drjattosolutionhome@gmail.com or website http://drjattosolutionhom.wixsite.com/solution or mobile +12564174927

      CRONHOES DISEAS

      MOLUSCUM

      BREAST ENLARGENT

      PENIS ENLARGEMENT

      BUMBS

      HERPES CURE

      .ALS CURE

      HIV CURE

      EPILEPSY

      PROMOTION IN THE OFFICE

      .LOVE SPELL

      .EX BACK

      INFERTILITY

      Delete
  3. What seems tricky to me though is that what the demand for money in a deflationary depression is quite different from the tight-money, high interest rate, pinch point that can foreshorten booms. The latter is a demand for monetary base needed for settlements the former is a demand for any sort of risk free broad money. It is very hard to satiate demand for broad money by increasing the monetary base isn't it?
    In the 1930s, not long after the (successful) initial devaluation of the USD versus gold, the US actually needed to buy up gold so as to prevent the USD appreciating back up versus gold and that was when interest rates were near the zero bound.

    ReplyDelete
  4. What I'm trying to say is that broad money is perhaps not a "good", rather (in its store of value role), it is an asset. As such its value comes from its ability to carry purchasing power through time until it can be used to buy say stocks once those are at a bargain price. Just as with any asset, having more of it around isn't what sets the price, its capacity to earn its way is what sets the price. If half of the companies in the SP500 were entirely bought up by a sovereign wealth fund, then after a year or so when things had settled down, the prices of the remaining stocks would not be altered. They would be worth what they earned and not overvalued "because there were fewer stocks being chased by the same amount of money".

    Goods are quite different from assets, goods get made and consumed, we want them for what they are not for transporting purchasing power through time. I guess collectables are a weird other class again because they neither earn nor get used up. I guess bitcoin and beanie babies are collectables. Perhaps houses are too. I don't think broad money can be thought of like that though.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Silver Gold Bull is the most trusted silver & gold dealer. They will provide you with competitive, live rates and they will make sure your precious metals are delivered to your door discreetly and fully insured.

    ReplyDelete
  6. (HOW I GOT CURED FROM GENITAL HERPES VIRUS )
    I was diagnosed with GENITAL HERPES VIRUS , my doctor told me it has no permanent cure, this virus affected me so badly that i was so ashamed of my self, this continued until a friend of mine Anna told me about Dr ejmen from west Africa who cured her mother from GENITAL HERPES VIRUS, I contacted this herbal doctor and he sent me the herbal medicine through courier service, when i received it i applied it for 1 week with the instruction and i was totally cured from GENITAL HERPES VIRUS permanently within 7 to 8 days of usage. if you are passing through the same problem you can contact him via his email you should know about his natural herbal treatment, Dr Ejmen email is been attached to my post reach him for help. drejmencurehome@gmail.com ‎ his contact number or whatsapp him +2349061828381.he can also cured this disease,HIV/AIDS,LOW SPERM COUNT,CANCER,ALS,HPV WARTS,HIGH BLOOD PRESSURE,STROKE,HEPATITIS B,DIABETES,PENIS ENLARGEMENT,HAIR GROW HERBAL CREAM,WEAK ERECTION,VAGINAL DISCHARGE,COLD SORE.

    ReplyDelete
  7. HELLO. I am happy and satisfied that is why i choose to support other patient that do not know about Dr Enoma, he cured me with his herbs and he also cured some patient i directed to him of HIV, Cancer Kidney stone, Diabetes etc. I am not ashamed to tell about how i suffered of Herpes for 16 years because i am completely negative now. Dr Enoma cured me and made my family happy again. you can contact him if you have any health issue. i assure you that you will get your desire granted through the help of Dr Enoma. contact him with his Email: dr.enomaspellhome@gmail.com or Call/Whatsapp +254785389290 FACEBOOK PAGE: https://www.facebook.com/dr.enomaherbalcure

    HELLO. I am happy and satisfied that is why i choose to support other patient that do not know about Dr Enoma, he cured me with his herbs and he also cured some patient i directed to him of HIV, Cancer Kidney stone, Diabetes etc. I am not ashamed to tell about how i suffered of Herpes for 16 years because i am completely negative now. Dr Enoma cured me and made my family happy again. you can contact him if you have any health issue. i assure you that you will get your desire granted through the help of Dr Enoma. contact him with his Email: dr.enomaspellhome@gmail.com or Call/Whatsapp +254785389290 FACEBOOK PAGE: https://www.facebook.com/dr.enomaherbalcure

    ReplyDelete
  8. HERPES CURE!!!!!!!! PLEASE READ AND SHARE

    I caught genital herpes from my ex boyfriend who never had any
    symptoms. I have had it for 4 years ,and it has affected my life. I have told my husband who I trusted about it and I have never had a bad reaction towards it but also seeking for alternative for me. People think herpes is really a minor skin irritation herpes has a long term effects on health. The stigma attached to this virus by ignorant people is ridiculous. Most people have herpes in one form or another. I would like to advise people on how i got rid of my herpes.i was reading a comment on the internet,and i saw a testimony posted by a woman from Ireland that she got rid of her herpes with the help of doctor oosa. i was so happy when i saw that post.i quickly collect the doctor oosa contact email and i email him within 5 hr he respond to my email.i explain things to him and he told me not to worry that he is going to help me. i ordered for his medicine product wish was sent to me via DHL that was how i got the herbal medicine.and i use it as i was told for the period of 3 weeks .after few weeks i found out that my herpes was no more and this was also confirm by my doctor.if you have herpes or other similar disease and you want cure,kindly contact doctor oosa via this email doctoroosaherbalhome@gmail.com or whatsapp him +359878394269

    ReplyDelete
  9. i want to use this medium to let every one know that HIV/AIDS has cure and that Dr Agbebaku is the solution. am Olivia Edward from Texas i was tested HIV/AIDS positive in july the year 2011, then ealy this month i read aticle about Dr Agbebaku having Hiv cure,i decided to look for him and lastly i was able to contact him through his email and phone number he told me everything that he needed and i play along too and he now then told me that he has prepared some local medicine that i need to drink it and he send it to me i axtually did as he directed, the later that night i was unable to sleep i urinate and toilet almost all the night i called him later that night to tell him how am feeling he told me that everything will be fine,few days later he called me and advice me that i should go to hospital to checked my status i actually did and i was now tested NEGATIVE i told everyboby right there at the hospital and i called him and thank him for his good work he told me to tell you out there if you knew you have this disease that you should contact him through his email [dragbebakuspellsolutiontemple@gmail.com] or whatsapp him on +2349053099479 or call him on +2349035850834. God Bless you

    ReplyDelete
  10. I am here to give a testimony about Dr. Uyi regarding HPV who cure me from it, i want to inform the general public how i was cured from (HUMAN PAPILLOMA VIRUS) by Dr. Uyi, i visited different hospital but they gave me different type of drugs but never cured me. I was browsing through the Internet searching for remedy on HPV and i saw comment of people talking about how Dr. Uyi cure herpes virus. When i contacted him he gave me hope and said not to worry that he can totally cure me, after little discussion he proceed with the preparation of the medicine and send it to me. Today, I am so happy as i am sharing this testimony. My advice to you all who thinks that there is no cure for HPV/HSV that is Not true just contact him and get cure by Dr. Uyi, He has different type of cure to so many disease/virus. You can contact him on his Email: uyiherbalmedicationcenter@gmail.com or WhatsApp him on +2348077199766.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Its obvious some patient with Herpes are been enslaved to the antiviral and other supplementary Orthodox medicine just to help suppress the virus and not a cure. I have been with the virus for 5 years, when i was introduced by a blogger who also narrated Her story online on how she was cured of Herpes virus after using Dr Oziengbe Herbal Medicine. I took the same step to also get cured of my Herpes, I made an order for Dr Oziengbe Herbal medicine and after taken for 2 weeks with a test result i was confirmed Herpes free. I have promised to keep telling good about this. You can Write him via his email: Dr.oziengbeherbalhealinghome@gmail.com and call or whatsapp him on +2347050577037..

    ReplyDelete
  12. Its obvious some patient with Herpes are been enslaved to the antiviral and other supplementary Orthodox medicine just to help suppress the virus and not a cure. I have been with the virus for 5 years, when i was introduced by a blogger who also narrated Her story online on how she was cured of Herpes virus after using Dr Oziengbe Herbal Medicine. I took the same step to also get cured of my Herpes, I made an order for Dr Oziengbe Herbal medicine and after taken for 2 weeks with a test result i was confirmed Herpes free. I have promised to keep telling good about this. You can Write him via his email: Dr.oziengbeherbalhealinghome@gmail.com and call or whatsapp him on +2347050577037..

    ReplyDelete
  13. Am testilying on how Dr Okoduwa cure me, i was diagnosed with Herpes for 3years ago i lived in pain with the knowledge that i wasn't going to ever be well again i contacted so many herbal doctors on this issue and wasted a large sum of money but my condition never got better i was determined to get my life back so one day i saw mr Martins post on how Dr Okoduwa saved him from the VIRUS with herbal medicine i contacted Dr Okoduwa on his email address Drokoduwahealingtemple@gmail.com we spoke on the issue i told him all that i went through and he told me not to worry that everything will be fine again so he prepared the medicine and send it to me through courier service and told me how to use it,after 14days of usage I went to see the doctor for test ,then the result was negative,am the happiest man on earth now. this testimony is real.thanks to Dr Okoduwa God bless you. you can also reach him on his whatsApp number +2347068877610

    ReplyDelete
  14. IT IS REAL!!! HOW I COMPLETELY GOT RID OF 6 YEARS GENITAL HERPES you can call or whatsapp this phone number (+2348161532663) Email:{drotubospellhome@gmail.com} WITHIN ( 3 )THREE WEEKS GOD IS GRAET ,I AM A LIVING TESTIMONY!!!!. I have been dating for almost 7 years until i contracted GENITAL HERPES VIRUS from my Ex-boyfriend who never told me he was having it.Ever since then i have been searchoing for cure everywhere because i was feeling so uncomfortable having so many outbreaks, Most people have herpes in one form or another, i was first taking Antiviral medicines such as acyclovir (Zovirax), famciclovir (Famvir), and valacyclovir (Valtrex), which are recommended for treating primary genital herpes outbreaks..But i needed to get rid of it completely, I came across so many testimonies online speaking about cure to herpes. i was so eager to be completely cured, I became a victim of fraud after contacting several so-called herbal doctors i was referred to. I lost a lot of money but i didn't stop searching for a cure. Then one faithful day,i came across a testimony of a lady saying that she got her Genital herpes cured by a GREAT HERBAL DOCTOR she called Dr. OTUBO by contacting him through his email address. And she advised anyone with GENITAL HERPES or SIMPLEX HERPES to contact him for HERBAL CURE. I contemplated for about 4 hours whether or not to contact him. Then something inside of me told me to give a try. I then contacted him through his email and told my problems to him. He told me all the things I needed to do and also gave me instructions to follow, Which i did properly. Just within the three weeks of drinking and applying the herbal medication he sent to me through DHL delivery service, I started feeling changes in my body i went to my medical doctor for check-up, I was so happy when he told me i was no more having GENITAL HERPES VIRUS and that i was free, It was all tears of Joy from that moment, I never thought ROOTS & HERBS could cure HERPES and if i could ever meet a GENUINELY GREAT HERBAL DOCTOR. I'm so grateful to him. i am completely free from GENITAL HERPES VIRUS,i recommended him to a family friend having Simplex Herpes virus, He called me and told me he is also cured completely. I promised to share my own testimony like that of the lady on the internet. If you are also having *GENITAL & SIMPLEX HERPES... or need cure to diseases/viruses like.. *EPSTEIN-BARR VIRUS *PREDIABETES/DIABETES/DIABETES MELLITUS... *MENINGITIS... *MERS-CoV... *HIV.. *LEISHMANIASIS... *LOW SPERM COUNT...A DRY VAGINA *SHIGELLA INFECTION... *SYPHILLIS *CANCER... *LOWER RESPIRATORY INFECTION... *STAPHYLOCOCCUS AUREUS... *HEPATITIS... *SHINGLES... *YELLOW FEVER... *POLIO... *LUPUS... *STROKE... *FIBROID... *EPILEPSY... *TUBERCULOSIS... *LEUKAEMIA... *SICKLE CELL... *ASTHMA.. Etc.. Without Hesitation Contact him Today for a testimony through his Email: (drotubospellhome@gmail.com) Good luck as you contact him.

    ReplyDelete